The Top 5 Desserts in Sarasota

Ready to satisfy your sweet tooth? Whether you’re on the hunt for a great bakery, the biggest scoop of ice cream, or a huge, gooey cookie, you’ll find some of the best desserts right here in Sarasota. Here are some of our top recommendations—give them a try and let us know what you think!

ofKours Bakery

Chia pudding and other desserts in Sarasota

After a busy day of exploring Sarasota, you might want to take a second to unwind with a delicious cup of coffee and a handmade sweet. If this is your idea of heaven, we have the perfect spot for you.

ofKourse Bakery is one of the most popular spots in town, and their endless list of desserts offers something for everyone. Even if you’re feeling a little health conscious, you can still indulge in their chia pudding or matcha superfood smoothies. Don’t forget to check out their lunch options, too!


Fudge and other desserts in Sarasota

Kilwins is a local legend, and one visit is all it takes to see why. Nestled just off of John Ringling Boulevard, this unassuming ice cream shop seems plain from the outside…but an explosion of amazing flavors awaits within.

This old-fashioned sweet spot offers everything from frozen treats to baked goodies, and they’re still using their original recipes from 1947. You can even order their most popular desserts online, including the world-famous Mackinac Island Fudge.

Pastry Art Bakery Cafe

Pain au chocolat

Pastry Art calls itself “Sarasota’s living room,” which might seem a little confusing until you stop in for a visit. This cozy eatery has been ranked as one of the area’s best coffee shops three times in a row, and the desserts are absolutely divine.

Sarasota residents have enjoyed Pastry Art for over 20 years, and there are a few standout menu items that you just have to try yourself. The baklava is both authentic and flaky, featuring a golden crust and a luscious filling. If you really want to wow a crowd, swing by and pick up a cake or some specialty pastries!

Gelato-go Sarasota

Gelato cup

Want to curb your gelato fix? Gelato-go has you covered. Stroll down South Orange Avenue to find this one-of-a-kind ice cream shop—you’ll know you’re in the right place when you see the bright red awning!

Wildberry, mango, limoncello, mascarpone, and chocolate are just a few of the amazing gelato flavors you can try here. They also offer coffee drinks, pastries, and even lunch specials. As if that’s not enough, Gelato-go can also deliver the perfect scoop right to your front door.

Le Macaron


Le Macaron is a French phenomenon that has taken Sarasota by storm! There’s no better place to find a wide variety of handcrafted pastries and sweets, but their macarons truly take the cake.

Local founders Rosalie Guillem and Audrey Guillem-Saba started selling their French-inspired goodies to the masses in 2009. By 2012, they began creating franchises all across Florida, but their gluten-free recipes still remain the same. Be sure to check them out!

Ready to Explore the Best Desserts in Sarasota?

Sarasota offers more than just desserts…we have an amazing restaurant, shopping, and entertainment scene, too! If you’re thinking about making a move to this one-of-a-kind city, just reach out to the Kotaska Team today. We have plenty of buying resources to get you started—just let us know how we can help.

Leave a Reply